# Findings: minimum-order-size-bitcoin-perpetuals (reviewed 2026-10-24) **Inputs.** `originals/` is empty: there is no author manuscript and no script. I checked everything against the images, the article's own numbers (`recheck.py`) and public endpoints that need no key. The raw responses are saved in `requery/`, with retrieval times in `_index.json`. The athenum-derivatives MCP was unavailable. ## Checklist lines 146 (en), 147 (ko), 148 (tr), 149 (ru), 150 (vi), 151 (de): CORRECTED All six rows carry the same claim: the four English alts (blocks 13, 18, 26, 38) joined together. **Correct as published:** - **Alt 13** matches the image. Ten venues move four or more places, and Deribit is ninth on the right. - **Alt 18:** - The kinks are right: 1/0.001, 5/0.001, 50/0.001, 5/0.0001 and 10/0.00001. Hyperliquid's kink is 12.48× the price of 80,099. - The flagged **2,000,000** is where the lines end (the 0.001 BTC line ends at about $2,000). - The alt was imprecise and is now fixed. Phemex's kink sits at the left edge, and above their kinks Phemex, Bybit and Binance share one green line. - **Alt 26:** every figure reproduces. - 91 pairs, 80 decidable, 11 tied, 34 wrong (42.5%). - 200,000 shuffles give a mean of 50.0% and a band of 28.75–71.25%. - Dropping one venue at a time gives 38.6% (without Binance) to 50.7% (without WOO X). - The flagged **90** is the visible histogram tail; the shuffles span 7.5% to 95%. - p = 0.51 reproduces as a two-sided mid-p (0.511). The inclusive and strict tails give 0.54 and 0.48, so the conclusion holds either way. - **Alt 38:** the numbers match the image. The shares recompute from $21.62B, and 0.66/0.75/0.83 recompute from the two ways of breaking the $10.00 tie. **Wrong (alt 38, blocks 37, 39, 40, 41, 43, 52, and the chart):** the open interest counted Bybit and Bitget on both sides of every position. - On 2026-08-25 the feed read Bybit `openInterestValue` and Bitget `size` without halving them (code at 5b25f65c9f). This was fixed only in 74e51775a5 on 2026-10-22. - Bybit's public hourly history shows `openInterest` at exactly 2 × `singleOpenInterest`. At 07:00 that is 47,902 against 23,951 BTC, about $3.86B against $1.93B (published $3.85B). - Bitget's v2 `size` equals its two-sided v3 `openInterest`, and the ratio is 2.000000 in all 30 rows. - Binance checks out against data.binance.vision: the BTCUSDT mean for 06:00–07:00 is $8.727B (published $8.73B). So each bar is one venue's main BTC perpetual, not all its perpetuals. **Counted once:** the total is **$18.32B**. Binance 47.7%, Hyperliquid 16.3%, OKX 12.8%, Bybit 10.5%, Bitget 7.5%, Deribit 5.2%. - Block 37's claim that the two venues with the most open interest also have the largest minimums becomes false: Hyperliquid is second, at $10.00. - The rank correlation falls from 0.66 to **about 0.36** (0.359). Three pairs share a rounded minimum: $80.10 (Binance and Bybit), $10.00 (Hyperliquid and Deribit) and $8.01 (Bitget and OKX). The 0.36 treats all three as ties. The eight ways of breaking those ties give **0.09 to 0.60**. My first draft treated only the $10.00 pair as a tie, which gave 0.26–0.49; that is replaced. - Hyperliquid, OKX and Deribit have no public history for that hour, so their figures stay as recorded. The feed read their one-sided fields: OKX `oi`/`oiCcy`, Hyperliquid `openInterest` and Deribit `open_interest`, all at 5b25f65c9f. OKX's history endpoint (`rubik`) returned an empty result, which is saved. - Bitget's 2026-08-25 value is two-sided by inference. Today the field the feed read equals Bitget's two-sided figure, exactly twice its one-sided one, and the note says we assume this held on 2026-08-25 too. - In ko, tr, ru, vi and de the alts are still in English. They should be localised from the reviewed alts. ## Other substantiated defects (English indices) - **14:** "Binance … comes out the dearest venue of the fourteen" contradicts block 6, which says calling any one of the five $80.10 venues the dearest "is a rounding artefact". It now says Binance comes last, in the group of five at about 80.10. - **43:** "Every number above comes from an endpoint you can call from a terminal with no account and no key" overclaims. Hyperliquid's $10 is documented, not returned by an endpoint, and the open interest comes from Athenum's own feed. The first sentence now names both exceptions; the second sentence ("Four steps…") is kept. Index 43 is the same in every locale. - **55:** "The 34 calculators" is out of date. The repo has 37 tool routes under `app/[locale]/tools/`, and the live /tools/ page says "37 free calculators". It now reads "37 tools", because two of them (odds-converter, prediction-market-fees) are not calculators by name. ## Checked and left unchanged - **Contract fields.** I re-queried every venue's public instrument endpoint on 2026-10-24 (16:09–16:10 UTC). Every field in the table and every value floor is unchanged since 2026-08-25, and the OKX and Bybit response bodies returned code 0. The values: - Binance: 0.001/0.001, minimum notional (`MIN_NOTIONAL`) 50. - Bybit: 0.001/0.001, minimum notional 5. - OKX: 0.01 (`minSz`, `lotSz`, `ctVal`). - Gate 1 × 0.0001. Bitget 0.0001, minimum 5 USDT. MEXC 1 × 0.0001. HTX 0.001. KuCoin 1 × 0.001. - WOO X 1e-05, minimum notional 0. Kraken 4. dYdX 0.0001. Deribit 10/10. Hyperliquid 5 decimals. Phemex 0.001, minimum order value 1. - The article already gives its read date, and the note records the re-query. - **Block 20:** Binance's hourly closes over the 168 hours run from $64,140 to $80,710 (the feed shows $64,127 to $80,669). The lowest low was $63,979, so the claim that the $50 floor never bound holds. The 08:33 close was $80,096, against the published mark of $80,099. - The 100× and 10.0× spreads, the 1/6/2/5 clusters, "ten times smaller" and "about $40" are correct. - Contract types are correct: Deribit is described as inverse, and the other contracts are linear. - Binance's $100 to $50 cut "with effect from 2026-04-14" (block 22) is not verified. Today's value is $50, which is consistent; the claim is kept as published and flagged in the note. ## Locale structure - English has 56 elements and the other five locales have 55. - **English block 53** ("It does not settle Hyperliquid's $10 by measurement…") **is missing in de, ko, tr, ru and vi**. That paragraph needs translating. - The only referenced index that differs is 55 → 54 (`indexmap.json`). Indices 0–52 are identical, checked by tag and content. - Figure 38 has to be redrawn; `figures.txt` gives the exact data, title, subtitle and footer. The reviewed alt 38 describes the redrawn chart, so the two must ship together.