7 days Pro+ free · no card

Trading journal: costs, decisions and honest performance · 3 / 4

Trade thesis changes: preserve the original plan and its revisions

A trade thesis may change as new information arrives. The journal should show that change, not make the original decision disappear. Keep immutable versions with their evidence, decision time and resulting action.

Athenum7 minUpdated:

Write a testable trade thesis and freeze it at entry

An actionable thesis specifies the observed condition, the expected behavior being tested, the invalidation and the allowed action. For example, a breakout acceptance rule needs a defined level, observation window and condition that rejects the hypothesis. A story about strong buyers without a rejection criterion cannot be audited in the same way.

At entry, freeze the thesis version, known data, proposed size and exit rule. Later notes append a new version and identify exactly what changed. Preserve original timestamps and source observations. A screenshot saved after the outcome can illustrate the review, but it does not prove what was visible before entry.

Widening a stop or adding size is a new risk decision

If a trader widens a stop, adds quantity or extends a time limit, calculate the new risk before acting. Calling the change an updated view does not remove its exposure. Keep the actual exchange instructions and acknowledgements alongside the intended action, since writing a new stop in a journal does not change the live order.

New evidence can justify a new hypothesis, but it does not retroactively validate the old one. If the original rejection condition occurs, record that result before opening a separate thesis. Avoid moving the rejection level repeatedly so the original trade is never allowed to fail.

Example: moving the stop from 96 to 93 on ten units

Assume each linear unit changes P&L by 1 USDT per one-point price move. In an original hypothetical example, version 1 at 09:00 buys ten linear units at 100 with an invalidation reference at 96: 40 USDT of price risk before costs. At 09:10, version 2 proposes moving the stop to 93 after new information. With quantity unchanged, risk from the original entry becomes 70.

If the 40 USDT budget covers only the remaining position measured from entry, floor(40 / 7) = 5 units gives 35 of remaining price risk. That is not a whole-trade loss limit: a reduction can already have realized a loss. Keep proposal, authorization and actual fills separate; preserve the original thesis.

Suppose the reduction fills at 98 and the remaining stop fills at 93, before costs. Closing five units loses 10; the remaining five lose 35: 10 + 35 = 45 exceeds the original 40 budget. With q units remaining, total loss is (10 − q) × 2 + q × 7 = 20 + 5q. Thus q ≤ 4: closing six loses 12 and four remaining lose 28, so 12 + 28 = 40. Fees or worse fills require additional capacity or a smaller position; a stop does not guarantee 93.

Worked example: a wider stop changes risk from 40 to 70
VersionRecorded timeEntry referenceStop referenceQuantityRemaining price risk from entry (USDT)
109:00100961040
2 proposed09:10100931070
2 size-constrained scenario09:1010093535
The chart shows only the remaining position’s price risk from entry, before costs; add realized reduction losses to test the whole-trade budget.Open full-size diagram
  1. Original plan: 40 USDT
  2. Wider stop, same quantity: 70 USDT
  3. Wider stop, five units: 35 USDT
The chart shows only the remaining position’s price risk from entry, before costs; add realized reduction losses to test the whole-trade budget.

Mistake: overwriting journal entries after the outcome

Overwriting the entry note after a favorable move makes the journal easier to read but weaker as evidence. The same problem occurs when a chart annotation is moved to the level that later worked. Keep the original, append the correction and explain the reason. A transparent rejected hypothesis teaches more than an apparently flawless history.

Before acting

  • Freeze the original conditions, size and invalidation.
  • Append evidence and timestamps for every revision.
  • Recalculate exposure before changing stops, size or holding time.
  • Verify actual order changes separately from written intent.

Check your understanding

Eight units entered at 50 with a stop reference of 47. A revision moves the stop to 45. With the original 24-unit cash risk allowance and whole-unit sizing, what maximum quantity fits before costs? Assume any reduction fills at the original entry price of 50, with no fees or slippage.

Show the explained answer

The new entry-to-stop distance is 5, so floor(24 / 5) = 4 units fit, with 20 of price risk. Keeping all eight would create 40 of price risk. Reducing quantity is a new executable action; its realized P&L and fees must be reconciled rather than omitted.

Sources and further reading

Continue with Athenum

Related lessons

Related courses